Brewster's Italian Cafe

Great Italian food served in a charming atmosphere, especially if you visit during the warmer months when garden dining is available. Located just off Whittacker Street in downtown New Buffalo.

A good place for pizza if you aren't into the pizza hut thing

The ambiance was relaxing and the food was good, however being asked to leave after dinner was a rude, unexpected surprise. There were 13 of us for dinner and after finishing our meal most of us left, but the four of us that were talking and relaxing, were asked rudely to leave due to the waiting time for others that arrived after us. I have never experienced this in my travels throughout the US or Europe. We were made to feel that it was our fault that the waiting time for others was so long rather than the restaurants' lack of seating. As a result of this experience, I won't recommend eating at this restaurant unless you're a fast eater and are prepared to leave as soon as you're done with you meal.

The ambiance was relaxing and the food was good, however being asked to leave after dinner was a rude, unexpected surprise. There were 13 of us for dinner and after finishing our meal most of us left, but the four of us that were talking and relaxing, were asked rudely to leave due to the waiting time for others that arrived after us. I have never experienced this in my travels throughout the US or Europe. We were made to feel that it was our fault that the waiting time for others was so long rather than the restaurants' lack of seating. As a result of this experience, I won't recommend eating at this restaurant unless you're a fast eater and are prepared to leave as soon as you're done with you meal.