S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill

I have lived here locally in the keys for 3 years now and this is still my favorite restaurant. they have the most amazing wreck salad that's to die. and your man will be happy too...lots of savory burgers and steaks too :) and if you're lucky you'll get to meet the resident stray cat who's such a sweetie. the wait staff there is very nice too.

My husband and I decided to try this restaurant out yesterday, we drive past it daily and had never been there. The atmosphere was nice, nothing fancy. Decent menu, little pricey for what we got. My husband got the Bronx Reuben with potato salad. The sandwich was great, but the potato salad had a very interesting taste neither of us could really figure out what it was. I am a vegetarian and was kinda excited that there were some vegetarian options. I tried the Wreck Pasta and was beyond disappointed. There was no flavor and I'm still trying to decide what the sauce was. It tasted like plain noodles with cooked basil, spinach, and sauteed tomatoes. I'm not the type that enjoys my pasta drenched in sauce, but there was no sauce to be found. So I asked for an extra side of sauce and received a bowl of the sauteed tomatoes in oil.... not quite what I was expecting. Then we get home and my husband is sick all night. I'm guessing that funky taste in the potato salad was that it had gone bad... So not a great experience...

The all you can eat snow crab is excellent but the music by Dan Sullivan makes this a truly great deal. Waiter, Chris always welcomes you with your favorite beverage and is attentive and friendly. Best value for a "date" night with all you can eat crab and a great show for under $30.