Reviews

Hi there!
Rate this business!
What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
SV
Sindi V.

04/10/2017

Overall
Atmosphere
Food
Service

It was beautiful,went with the family n they loved it n the service was great n the food was delicious!will go again soon.

christoperanderson20

03/01/2011

Provided by Superpages
Overall

i recommend this place, tumbs up! i like the service the place and everything :)

edwina.reader4720

02/23/2011

Provided by Superpages
Overall

The food is excellent, service is always good, and the atmosphere is great. That's why it's Zagat rated because it a special restaurant. Jonathan's is a very special place for the wife and I. We enjoy dining here all the time and I have never been disappointed. I believe you will find it to be special to.

anonymous

01/16/2011

Provided by Superpages
Overall

Read all the goooofy reviews, don't be fooled, don't take them seriously. I eat there all the time and the food is unbeleivable - Pizza is VERY GOOD. Try their grandma pie with Sausage and the antipasto salad - won't regret it!. The sauce is so good they should sell it by the gallon and YES meat is fine there. Another fave - shrimp parm hero, it's Wow. Also their fried calamari is great. Cheesecake is outrageous and Canoli too! Portions are huge. Tuesdays is pasta night is the best. Owner is always there watching quality control and if you don't like something say so, they fix in a flash. Had a so so meal once in 6 years. How's that for a record. Oh and the staff is super nice and NO they are not all italian but guess what people some of the best Italian food is made by Hispanic cooks - that's the reality in NYC kitchens so don't be shocked (for all the racist wannabe foodies). PS. price wise, yes some are expensive but well worth a good meal.

anonymous

12/07/2010

Provided by Superpages
Overall

The best Thai food I've ever eaten!! Wonderful decor and the new owners are the nicest!

jcaldoo

08/14/2010

Overall
Horrible Food

Mystery food, the worst Italian food I have ever had the displeasure of eating. Steer clear of this establishment.

jackmioff

08/14/2010

Overall
HIGHEST PRICED PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND !!!

$13.00 for 2 specialty slices and a soda, This place is a joke. BEWARE MY FRIENDS, This place is a MAJOR RIP OFF !!!

anonymous

08/06/2010

Provided by Superpages
Overall

I didn't think the pizza was anything to eave about. I have some concerns about eating anything from here containing meat. They are not known for freshness. Take a look at their boorah & urbanspoon ratings for yourself and decide. If you have the time and the money file for their health department report.

anonymous

04/08/2010

Provided by Superpages
Overall

You don't need to be Italian to make Pizza. You don't even need to speak English.Bread dough cheese and tomato sauce such a difficult art to master.I think that it takes more brains to deliver a Pizza than make one.

anonymous

03/03/2010

Provided by Superpages
Overall

Way over priced for there so so pizza,they need to hire Italians to make the pizza.

nylilady

02/10/2006

Provided by Superpages
Overall
A local favorite of mine till we moved but will visit every time I'm back to area.

the food is great. the service is great. every time we have gone it has been great, we have moved away from the area but plan on going back for a visit and this is going to be the first place we eat at. would love to get them to open a place out where we live now.

Details

Phone: (631) 587-2251

Address: 761 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704

Website: http://www.cafe-gio.com

More Info

General Info
Cafe Gio doesn't require reservations! Come and enjoy our large, Italian menu consisting of delicious, Neapolitan and artisan pies, fresh salads, seafood, pastas, entrees and more.Cafe Gio doesn't require reservations! Come and enjoy our large, Italian menu consisting of delicious, Neapolitan and artisan pies, fresh salads, seafood, pastas, entrees and more.
Email
Payment method
master card, visa, amex, discover
Price Range
$$
Neighborhood
West Babylon
Categories
Other Information

Cuisines: Cafeterias, Italian, European, Continental

Price Range : Average

People Also Viewed