Find a business

        Reviews

        Hi there!
        Rate this business!
        What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
        Click to Rate
        BD
        Brian D.

        10/11/2023

        Overall
        Ambiance
        Food
        Service

        Best thin crust pizza around. Ask for it well done.
        Usually busy, but worth it.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        HA
        Henry A.

        02/13/2016

        This icon signifies the review was contributed by a participant in the YP for Schools program
        Overall

        The pizza at the Star Tavern is consistently rated and voted the best in Essex County New Jersey. The pizza is great -- thin style with a sweet sauce. The lasagna is also excellent -- try it out when you want something other than a pizza. If you eat-in, expect a bit of a wait at peak dining hours.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        anonymous

        02/07/2015

        Provided by Superpages
        Overall

        Best thin crust pizza around. Wings and fries are great too!

        Helpful(0)Flag
        robert.levy.31

        10/08/2012

        Overall
        worst SERVICE ever...great food...order to go, and that is a hastle at best....

        the worst service ever...if your looking for a fun night out, LOOK SOMEWHERE ELSE...worst help anywhere

        Helpful(0)Flag
        anonymous

        04/03/2009

        Provided by Superpages
        Overall

        Posted on 04/04/09 on "Yahoo Food, Slice America", Pizza Showdown:The Best Delivery Pizza" (my comment):""Wondering if the reviewers were from California??? Ever walk into a Pizzeria on the East Coast and smell the cheese? Ever tasted dough made from other than flour and water? notice the genuine bubbling effect of the dough? or the browning effect of the upper layer? taste genuine Italian pizza sauce vs spaghetti sauce? Gone are the days of the authentic Italian Pizza--Star Pizzeria in Orange, NJ with it's reputation for 40 years plus as the ultimate best, where folks make a point to stop from Coast-to-Coast. By the way, if pizza topped with pineapple was ever delivered in any of the Godfather movies, they would have taken the delivery guy to the mattresses-- it's not authentic and it's not "real" Italian... it's like New York Cheese Cake made in China... it's like "being told by those who think they know to those that do [know]." Reviewers need a trip back East."

        Helpful(0)Flag

        Details

        Phone: (973) 675-3336

        Address: 400 High St, Orange, NJ 07050

        Website: http://www.startavern.net

        More Info

        General Info
        The Star Tavern has been a traditional family favorite for delicious, thin crust pizza served hot and lively in an atmosphere humming with over 75 years of neighborhood character. Come try what The New York Times calls "superior" pizza, The Star Ledger claim it the "best thin crust pizza in NJ", and NJ.com declares is "a Jersey pizza shrine".The Star Tavern has been a traditional family favorite for delicious, thin crust pizza served hot and lively in an atmosphere humming with over 75 years of neighborhood character. Come try what The New York Times calls "superior" pizza, The Star Ledger claim it the "best thin crust pizza in NJ", and NJ.com declares is "a Jersey pizza shrine".
        Extra Phones

        Fax: (973) 675-4420

        Payment method
        amex, cash, master card, paypal, visa
        AKA

        Star Tavern & Pizzeria

        Other Links

        http://www.startavern.net

        https://www.startavern.net

        Categories
        Taverns, Bar & Grills, Bars, Brew Pubs, Night Clubs, Restaurants
        Other Information

        Cuisines: Bar & Grills, Brew Pubs

        People Also Viewed

        View similar Taverns
        Suggest an Edit